What People say about Us

Todd & Melissa Hutchins – Kokomo

“Don was a great help when shopping for insurance. Good service, thorough explanations of coverage, and saved us some money over our last agency.”


Thomas W & Susan K Tooley – Russiaville

“I’ve had insurance with the Killingbeck’s for over 25 years. No worries, no surprises! Killingbeck Insurance means dependability and responsibility. Thanks for your service.”


Deborah Lot ­– Kokomo

“You saved me over half on my car & truck insurance on full coverage. You insure my Business. You beat all other quotes. You have been most helpful each time I call with a question. And I don’t feel like a stranger when I enter your Business. Thank you, Bill you are Great!”


John H & Carol A Miller – Kokomo

“The Killingbeck’s are the first insurance agency I’ve ever had. They make me feel like I am one of the family. They’ll do anything they can to help me get the best policies & prices for me.”


Andrea Hale – Russiaville

“Killingbeck Ins. Agency not only has saved me money on my Home & Auto Ins. Their service is impeccable.”


Robert E & Deborah E Lynas – Galveston

“We feel very lucky to have a family Insurance Agency like Killingbeck to care for all of our Insurance needs from taxes, car, home and assistance on updates through the years. We appreciate your kindness and experience that gives us peace of mind. Thank You very much Bob & Deb Lynas”


Rebecca L Matthews – Kokomo

“I’ve just switched to Killingbeck so I haven’t had any claims. But I switched because it was much less that my previous insurance. Both auto & homeowners, and there is no extra charge for automatic pay. I liked the way I was treated also.”


Melven & Kathern I Fowler – Russiaville

“Your insurance agency has always got us the insurance that would be the best for us at the right price, and we get our taxes fixed at your agency too.”


Charles H & Polly J Lorensberg – Windfall

“We have never had to file a claim yet, but you did give us the best price on our vehicle insurance when merged with our homeowners insurance. We also have had our taxes done there for many years.”


George & Gail Winner – Kokomo

“I had my homeowners insurance with American Family & my auto ins. with GMAC, my homeowners insurance was going up 20% to 30% every year with new claims filed. When I changed to the Killingbeck Agency I saved a lot on both auto & homeowners, and the premiums actually went down when I renewed the 2nd year. Any questions I have had were answered with one call to the office. I highly recommend them to all my friends.”


Beverly A Snodgrass – Kokomo

“I haven’t filed any claims but feel there is no need to worry about anything as you will take care of it.”


John W & Kathryn A Sharpe – Kokomo

“Your office has always been prompt in returning phone calls & answering any questions we have.” Thanks for good service!


Holly J Lamb – Kokomo

“When I came to you for new rates (lower than what I had), you found just what I wanted, same coverage for less money on both my cars and home. You were very through in finding the right policies. You were recommended to me, and you lived up to what I was told about your agency.”


Douglas W & Judith E Hamilton – Greentown

“Your constant attention to my insurance cost and coverage, in offering to review insurance needs to determine if it matches insurance coverage, saving money by changing insurance carriers.”


Robert Pham – Kokomo

“Good service! I would recommend its services to friends of mine.”


Teresa L & Kenneth Long – Kokomo

“My daughter id turning 16 shortly, Don Killingbeck was so great in helping us with all of our questions when deciding to purchase her a car. We wanted to save on our insurance rates and Don was able to help us do this. Thanks Killingbeck for always caring enough to help your customers!” J


Gregory & Sara Skulicz – Kokomo

“Doug K. found us money, saving auto and homeowners policies that maintained our previous coverage’s at lower cost. This and affordable payment plans was reason to switch to Killingbeck Insurance.”


Nona K & Jerrold L Anthony – Kokomo

“Through the many years we have been with you, we often compare insurance rates and you have always been comparative in price. In addition we find that we are dealing with people of integrity and honesty. We consider your friendship as agents. Many times you have helped us on other matters and gone that extra mile. Thank You, Nona & Jerrold Anthony.”


David G & Elaine Watson – Kokomo

“We did have a window break on the truck, called insurance she got truck in and fixed within 24 hours. I had no problem. Thank You.”


Charles J & Shirley Alder – Frankfort

“Our agent is Dave Killingbeck. Dave’s knowledge on taxes and insurance is unsurpassed. Dave’s advice is always in our best interest. Honesty and devoted to the client are two words Killingbeck Insurance stands for!”


Maggie P Patterson – Kokomo

“I have been a client with the Killingbeck Insurance Agency for several years, and the entire Killingbeck group has been prompt in helping me with all my claims and insurance matters. Thanks! Maggie Patterson.”


Allan E & Carlyn D Laubenstein – Kokomo

“Killingbeck personnel know the policies they handle in detail and are thus able to recommend policies that fit my particular needs. You always get to talk to a human being, rather than a computer.”


Jack & Amy Kaufman - Burlington

“We called Don Killingbeck one morning for a free auto + homeowners quote. That afternoon I asked when can we sign! We increased our coverage + saved money! They are “all” very friendly!”


Doug & Judy Hamilton - Kokomo

“They combined home & auto insurance to save me money. They helped settle a claim that was not their job to do. The other drivers insurance was slow to pay. They continually review my insurance needs to assure proper coverage.”


Esther France – Peru

“Not only did I save over $200 on my homeowners insurance, they were the exact opposite of most businesses today. Killingbeck was warm, prompt, and personal. They went the “extra mile”. I feel very good about this business relationship.


William & Rita Thompson – Galveston

Your agency was most helpful when looking for motorcycle insurance. We had got quotes back from other agencies and by internet and your coverage and pricing was the “Best.” Thanks for your help on taking care of our needs.


Kevin Elliott – Westfield

The staff has been very helpful in answering my questions and has always promptly mailed me any requested information.


Victoria & Jeffery Phelps – Kokomo

Killingbeck helped to keep our insurance cost down even with a 17 year old boy in the house!


Mike Freeman – Kokomo

I feel comfortable working with the staff of Killingbeck. I feel they are honest and hardworking to make sure their customers are satisfied. They are prompt in communication and mailing to me and I am satisfied with everything they have done with me.


Patrick & Lori Dowell

I called, got a quote over the phone within a few minutes and signed my paperwork the next day! Very helpful & courteous – ps I also get my taxes done at your agency about 10 years now!


Ken Shoup Tamara Johnson

Not only did we get the best rate but we were treated like family.


Dennis & Mary-Ann Cullison

We left our previous agency because premiums kept rising, leaving us to shop around for better premiums. Hope your agency can possibly review our situation on a yearly basis. This would help keep our premiums low. Thanks.


Nita J. Wright

Several years ago, I signed on with Hartford Ins and was re-assured that I was receiving the best rates available for my auto and homeowners ins. After years of increasing premiums and no at=fault claims and frustrations re: talking to machines and being transferred from one person to another and still not getting satisfactory answers to questions. I began shopping around for more personable service and better coverage/rates. I feel I’ve found it all and more with Killingbeck. Thank you!


Jason Harner & Megan Ewing

This was the first time I have got insurance on my own and Don made it very easy to do. He saved me so much money I tell everyone I know about Killingbeck Insurance. You guys are the best J


Mary Whitehead

I transferred all my insurance to Killingbeck because of the rates and customer service. They’re a great bunch of people to deal with.


Tina Granson

I tried working with my previous agent to keep my insurance at a reasonable cost when my kids started driving, they couldn’t help me. I called Killingbeck’s and they saved me over $1,000 – per year instantly. I switched everything cars and house and couldn’t be happier.


Claims Testimonials


Shirley Bugher – Kokomo

When I needed help in getting the police report I called the Killingbeck Office and they got the report when I couldn’t so I could proceed to get my car fixed that was much appreciated.


Phillip Deardorff – Kokomo

Very good service.


Daniel Mahoney – Kokomo

The people at Killingbeck were very helpful and didn’t get mad when we asked questions. The adjustor was very nice and helpful.


Jeff Fisher – Kokomo

Accident occurred in Georgia 4-8-06. At present time will pay my deductable ($1000) toward fixing car. Claim is against semi who struck me. Hope to get my deductable back & have 0 claims against my policy – time will tell.


Betsy Haberfield – Indianapolis

I enjoy the personal and friendly service that I receive from Killingbeck Insurance. Thank you!


Billy & Faith Davis – Forest

Was very polite and handled the claim fairly quickly.


Kylene Rayls – Indianapolis

Service was prompt which is most appreciated!


Jon Weaver – Cicero

Broken windshield. Your staff handled my broken windshield claim quickly & courteously & Pekin referred me to a repair facility that was equally pleasant.


Boyd Piercy –

I have $500.00 deductibles & I have the equipment & tools to fix it myself for less than $500.00.


Greg Hall – Sharpsville

Your representative was able to walk my daughter through the claim process so she had no questions.


Melissa Anthony - Kokomo

I over corrected, which sent the car sideways into a field, hitting an embankment. Everything was taken care of surprisingly fast. Unfortunately, it was a total loss. The adjustor worked well with my schedule & took care of everything nicely Thank you.


Gilbert Phelps – Kokomo

Adjuster Freedom Williams was great. He took care of everything in a very professional manor and made a bad experience good.


Tamma Benedict – Kokomo

They took care of it very fast and were very polite. In every part of my claim it was fast and everything came together perfect. No complaint.


Stephen Wright – Kokomo

They were very friendly, very courteous, very quick in getting my estimate & saved me over $500. I will be moving my other insurance to Killingbeck also.


Amy Schaeffer – Greentown

When I traded from an 03’ Jeep to an 06’ truck, Allstate wanted to raise my rate $100 more a month! Killingbeck’s was able to find my insurance on the truck for less than I was paying Allstate for my 3 year-old Jeep! I would recommend Killing becks to everyone I know.


Michael Phipps

I received my claim check much sooner than I expected. No questions asked.


Gary Bitner

They were very understanding about my problem. They took care of it very quickly. I am glad I have my insurance with Pekin & Killingbeck Insurance. Thank you and God Bless.


Phillip & Michelle Ennis

Killingbeck was very helpful. Our claim experience was very stressful and difficult but Killingbeck helped and we are very thankful.


Gloria McMasters

Everyone I contacted about my car was very helpful and I was very satisfied.


Norma Mooney - Kokomo

My claim was taken care of OK. I was satisfied. Sorry about my writing. I’m nervous.


Jacueline Hunt – Kokomo

Your agency follow-up with Indiana Farmers made the claim possible. After the company understood the policy, the claim was handled very quickly. All repairs are complete.


John and Kathy Ross

Representatives were prompt and helpful with frequent updates about progress on the claim status. We even learned some new insurance terminology. Both Farmers and Killing becks provided excellent service.


John Cotner

Auto accident with total loss of vehicle. Pekin rep was quickly responsive and offered fair settlement for losses.


Billy S. Hoover

Prompt assessment and payment of claim. The Arnie Cook Co. was very slow to show up and the clean-up after job was shoddy.


Alvin Laughner

Vandals sprayed oven cleaner on our Suburban (3 sides). I got 2 estimates & chose Strega’s Body Shop (who did excellent work as usual). I got my check in just a few days. Thanks Much!


Matthe & Kris Hetzner

Being our first (and hopefully last) claim experience, everyone at Killingbeck’s & Pekin have been the best.


Lila Rombold

Everyone I spoke to was very helpful. The claim check was sent promptly. MD Contracting out of Galveston is a good company. This is the first time I have used them and they did nice work. I would use them again if needed.


Ray & Kemberly Ragan

After I called your office about the fire and the Fire Dept. gave and got info both parties needed we were contacted by Brock Westfall about an hour later. Brock has been EXTREMELY helpful with assisting us during this difficult time and his very prompt service has been extremely appreciated. We are now in the process of getting a new barn selected and rebuilt. We have been able to also get some of the items we lost to the fire replaced already, thus helping to get our horses back home in a safe place again. For all the kindness and thoughtfulness from your whole company we are grateful and extremely thankful we choose your company for our insurance carrier!



Ronald Tooley

Notified agent a claims agent came 4 days later gave a check for repairs.


Cottingham, Michael

Helped us out a lot. Were able to still take our vacation which was to start on 8-28-06. Response time from your company was immediate and very helpful. Thank you.


Sarah Mason

Everything was fine.


Robert E. Dishon

The adjuster Brock Westhall was very courteous & Polite, settled my claim fast


James Hackler

Another driver was responsible for the accident. Your agency filed the accident report for me. You also provided me with the other driver’s insurance claims representative name, claim number, etc. Everything is resolved except rental car charges.


Ernest Cottingham

It had been at least 25 years since I had been in any kind of accident and we were a long way from home! After contacting Killingbeck, they made me feel better (I was feeling extremely bad) and they took care of my accident issues quickly. When dealing with Killingbeck, I always feel like a valuable customer & friend. Thank you.


Kelly Yeakel

Everyone I dealt with during this experience was thorough and extremely friendly and patient. That’s a great relief when dealing with these kinds of situations. Thank you!


Maureen Mcclain

I had an accident in Carmel, IN and the following day my dad called Bill. He then contacted a rep in the Indy area (Heather). She was very nice and helpful. I checked in on the progress of my car and it should be done this week. Thanks for your help!


Arthur W Grant

I filed a claim Wednesday morning. The adjustor called same day. He said I would get a check the coming Monday. We received the check and we picked up our car Thursday.

Shanon Lusher

When I came to the office, everyone was friendly, helpful & sympathetic. They promptly contacted Pekin and Got me in touch with the person I needed to talk to.


Barbie Sirmons

Water heater flooded lower level on Sunday. Called Killingbeck Mon AM. Claims adjuster contacted me by Wed. Very helpful. Has made the experience very tolerable.


Jeffrey McCrumb

Came in with a claim against another company it was taken care of very prompt.


Victor & Kimberlee Atwell

Though all but medical claims were pushed through the opposing insurance company, everyone was friendly, helpful and willingly walked us through the entire process. They were great.


Phillip & Michell Rigsby

The whole claims process was great. I received a call from your claims rep the same day that I turned the claim in. Hopefully, I never have another claim, but if I do, I know Pekin Ins. Will be there for me.


Mary Henry

I called to see if my homeowners would cover a bad place in my bathroom floor. My son-in-law fixed it so I didn’t need to use my insurance. Had I needed to, everyone was prompt and friendly! I’m sure it would have been a pleasant experience.


Shirley Bugher

Every thing was great there is only on thing I didn’t understand and have question about is why if insurance paid for car rental where I still had to pay for each rental car insurance out of pocket $138.


Sharon Darling

Everone was very helpful! Kept in touch letting us know progress. Body shot very good really pleased on time it was done.


Carol Calabro

The process was in motion as soon as I reported the accident to Killingbeck. I didn’t have any problems. I delivered the car to McGonigals. Received the check from Pekin and picked up the repaired car. There was a rattle in the repaired car it also seemed to skimmy. I took it back to McGonicgals. They tightend the hood. That took care of the rattle. They said I needed to take it over to the service dept. and have the tires rotated and wheels balanced. I asked if the accident could have caused the vibration problem. They said, “no”. It runs fine and looks great! I’m happy.


Paige Pine

It is 12-15-06 and I still don’t know if my medical bills and car rental will be paid. Not sure who is at fault.


Alan Lawson

Claim done & checks received & Killingbeck helpful when needed.


Bennette & Patricia Lewis

Our house was destroyed in a fire. Met with adjuster on 1/4/07. He said he would turn in information and we should hear something in 2 to 3 weeks. We are just waiting now for some word. Any help you could give to expedite this situation would be greatly appreciated.



Everyone was very helpful and courteous. I gave a statement about the accident to the insurance company in Fort Wayne and they were courteous to me.


Ryan Widmer

Had a billing issue with repair facility, but it was resolved without further issues.


David Carter II

My experience has been very good thanks to the help Don Killingbeck provided. He went above and beyond what was required and expected. I truly appreciate you all. “Thank You.”


John Fridley

Everything was delayed by the snow storm which wasn’t anyone’s fault. Otherwise, things went well.


Evelyn Padfield

The gentleman that backed into us was admit ably wrong gave us all info on his insurance company. She was very cooperative. Killingbeck Insurance did their part as usual – The repair shop is the greatest.


Brian McGavic

We notified your office about our accident. A single estimate was submitted, and approved. Our van was repaired within a few weeks.


Ronald Orttel

It was so important when Dave answered the phone. After speaking to him, I began to feel that everything was going to be O.K. Contact with the adjustor could have been a little faster, but Beau was very cordial and helpful when we met. It’s been 3 weeks since our loss, repairs have not begun yet. Unable to rate satisfaction as yet.


Leo Smith

Our claim experience was painless since we used a preferred repair center, Conkle Pontiac. We are schedules to have Conkle Pontiac complete the body repairs the week of June 6th.


Nina Coombs

Very Good.


Beverly Roe

Everyone was helpful and nice. They got me a rental car. My car was perfect in the amount of time. I was very happy with the outcome.


Mary Dungan-Klemme

The claims representative was kind and the check was sent right away.


Penelope Grainger

Unbelievably great. Everyone was extremely helpful, courteous, and went beyond great. Thanks.